Strategies for Cultivating Innovation and Creativity in Leadership

In the contemporary dynamic business environment, characterized by rapid technological advancements and heightened competition, fostering innovation and creativity within leadership teams is paramount for organizational success. This necessitates a strategic approach that transcends traditional management paradigms. This article explores fifteen evidence-based strategies for cultivating a culture of innovation, drawing upon organizational behavior theories and best practices.

Key Concepts

Before delving into the strategies, it’s crucial to define some key concepts. Innovation refers to the process of translating an idea or invention into a good or service that creates value or for which a market exists. Creativity is the generation of novel and useful ideas. A growth mindset, as defined by Carol Dweck, emphasizes the belief that abilities and intelligence can be developed through dedication and hard work, contrasting with a fixed mindset that views these traits as innate and unchangeable. Organizational culture encompasses the shared values, beliefs, and norms that shape employee behavior and interactions. Psychological safety, a crucial element of a positive work environment, refers to a shared belief held by team members that the team is safe for interpersonal risk-taking.

Strategies for Fostering Innovation

1. Cultivating a Growth Mindset: Implementing a growth mindset framework within the organization, as per Dweck’s research, encourages employees to embrace challenges as learning opportunities. This involves providing constructive feedback, celebrating effort and progress, and reframing setbacks as valuable learning experiences. Real-world application includes incorporating regular feedback sessions focused on development, not just performance reviews, and providing training in problem-solving and resilience techniques.
2. Establishing Open and Transparent Communication Channels: Promoting open communication, leveraging theories of organizational communication, ensures a free flow of ideas. This can be achieved through regular brainstorming sessions, suggestion boxes, and the utilization of collaborative platforms that facilitate idea sharing and feedback. The application of active listening techniques by leaders is crucial to building trust and encouraging participation.
3. Leveraging Diversity and Inclusion for Enhanced Creativity: Building upon the social identity theory, diverse teams bring varied perspectives, leading to more creative problem-solving. This requires proactive diversity and inclusion initiatives in recruitment, promotion, and team composition, coupled with fostering an inclusive environment where all voices are respected and valued. This fosters a sense of belonging, a crucial element of effective teamwork and innovation, as posited by the social capital theory.
4. Providing Resources and Empowering Employees: Resource Dependence Theory highlights the importance of access to resources for successful innovation. Leaders should provide employees with the necessary tools, technologies, budget, and training to explore and develop their ideas. This empowers individuals, fostering a sense of ownership and accountability that enhances productivity and commitment.
5. Establishing Clear Goals and Expectations: Applying Goal-Setting Theory, leaders must clearly articulate the organization’s vision, strategic goals, and performance expectations. This provides direction and alignment, focusing efforts on innovation that contributes to the overall strategic objectives. This clear direction also reduces ambiguity and provides a sense of purpose for employees.
6. Fostering Collaboration Through Cross-Functional Teams: Promoting cross-functional collaboration, drawing upon concepts from team dynamics and organizational structure, allows for the exchange of ideas and perspectives across different departments. This cross-pollination can spark innovative solutions to complex problems by bringing together diverse skill sets and perspectives. Matrix organizational structures can support this strategic approach.
7. Creating a Culture of Psychological Safety and Experimentation: Establishing a culture of psychological safety, as defined by Amy Edmondson, where employees feel comfortable taking risks and expressing ideas without fear of negative consequences is crucial. This involves explicitly stating that failure is a learning opportunity, encouraging experimentation, and providing constructive feedback rather than punishment for mistakes. This facilitates risk-taking and innovation.
8. Allocating Dedicated Time for Creative Problem Solving: Scheduling dedicated time for creative thinking and idea generation, applying principles of time management and resource allocation, allows employees to focus their energies on innovation. This might involve brainstorming sessions, hackathons, or dedicated “innovation days,” allowing for focused exploration of new ideas outside the routine work schedule.
9. Recognizing and Rewarding Innovation: Applying reinforcement theory, leaders must acknowledge and reward employees for their innovative ideas and contributions. This could involve financial incentives, public recognition, or opportunities for professional development. This positive reinforcement strengthens innovative behaviors.
10. Facilitating Knowledge Sharing and External Learning: Encouraging employees to engage in professional development activities, such as attending conferences, workshops, and networking events, facilitates knowledge acquisition and external inspiration. This broadens perspectives and encourages the adoption of best practices from other organizations and industries, enriching the organization’s innovative capacity.
11. Promoting Employee Ownership and Autonomy: Empowering employees with autonomy and ownership over their work, based on self-determination theory, increases motivation and innovation. Delegating responsibility and providing decision-making authority encourages employees to take ownership of their projects, fostering creativity and commitment.
12. Investing in Continuous Learning and Development: Supporting continuous learning through training programs, mentoring, and knowledge-sharing initiatives enhances employees’ skills and knowledge, fueling innovation. Investing in employees’ development signals a commitment to growth and creates a culture of continuous improvement, which enhances the organization’s capacity for adaptation and innovation.
13. Building a Positive and Supportive Work Environment: Cultivating a positive work environment characterized by trust, respect, and psychological safety fosters creativity and innovation. This involves fostering strong team dynamics, promoting open communication, and addressing conflict constructively. A positive work environment reduces stress and enhances collaboration, improving creativity and problem-solving.
14. Implementing Idea Management Systems: Utilizing technology platforms for idea generation, evaluation, and management provides a structured approach to capturing and developing innovative ideas. These systems facilitate collaboration and ensure that ideas are not lost or overlooked, effectively harnessing the collective intelligence of the organization.
15. Leading by Example: Leaders must model the desired behaviors, showcasing a willingness to take calculated risks, embrace failures as learning opportunities, and actively encourage innovation. This inspires and motivates employees to adopt a similar approach, creating a culture of innovation from the top down. This exemplifies transformational leadership, impacting organizational culture through inspiring and motivating employees.

Conclusions and Recommendations

Fostering a culture of innovation requires a multifaceted approach that integrates various organizational behavior theories and management strategies. The strategies outlined above offer a comprehensive framework for cultivating creativity and driving organizational success. However, the specific application of these strategies will vary depending on the organization’s size, industry, and existing culture. Successful implementation requires a commitment from leadership at all levels, effective communication, and ongoing evaluation to ensure alignment with organizational goals. Further research could explore the effectiveness of different combinations of these strategies across various organizational contexts. The impact of integrating these strategies will manifest in enhanced organizational performance, increased competitiveness, improved employee engagement, and the development of novel products and services. The applicability extends to organizations of all sizes and across diverse sectors.

Reader Pool: What are the potential limitations and challenges in implementing these innovation strategies, and how might these be addressed to maximize their effectiveness?

Strategies for Cultivating Employee Loyalty and Fostering Career Growth

In today’s dynamic business landscape, the acquisition and retention of high-performing employees are paramount to organizational success. This necessitates a strategic approach to employee retention and career development, grounded in effective leadership and robust human resource management (HRM) principles. This article explores key strategies to cultivate an environment that not only retains talent but also empowers individual professional growth and advancement. We will analyze these strategies through the lens of various organizational behavior theories and models such as Herzberg’s Two-Factor Theory, expectancy theory, and social exchange theory, among others.

Strategic Compensation and Benefits Design: Competitive remuneration is critical for attracting and retaining top talent. This encompasses not merely base salary but a holistic compensation package including comprehensive benefits (health insurance, retirement plans, paid time off, etc.) to ensure work-life balance and overall job satisfaction. Compensation should be regularly reviewed and adjusted to align with industry benchmarks and market dynamics, reflecting principles of equity theory which posits that employees compare their inputs and outputs to those of others. Failure to maintain competitive compensation can lead to decreased job satisfaction and increased employee turnover, as predicted by equity theory.

Cultivating a Culture of Recognition and Rewards: Employee recognition and rewards are crucial for boosting morale and motivation. Implementing a formal recognition program that highlights exceptional performance through both monetary and non-monetary rewards (public acknowledgment, promotions) reinforces positive behavior and contributions, aligning with reinforcement theory. This demonstrates organizational appreciation and enhances job satisfaction and commitment, reinforcing the social exchange between employer and employee, as described in social exchange theory.

Investing in Employee Growth and Development: Providing clear career progression pathways, mentorship programs, and ample skill development opportunities fosters employee engagement and retention. This aligns with expectancy theory, which suggests that employees are more motivated when they believe their efforts will lead to desired outcomes (career advancement). Regular performance reviews provide constructive feedback and guidance, supporting goal setting and achievement, a key component of goal-setting theory.

Fostering a Positive and Supportive Work Environment: A positive organizational culture is foundational to employee retention. A supportive atmosphere characterized by open communication, collaboration, and mutual respect fosters a sense of belonging and psychological safety. This aligns with the principles of organizational justice, impacting job satisfaction and reducing turnover. Actively creating opportunities for both personal and professional development underscores the organization’s commitment to employee well-being, further enhancing engagement and retention.

Promoting Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DE&I): Active promotion of DE&I principles creates a more inclusive workplace where all employees feel valued, regardless of background or identity. This strengthens organizational culture and improves employee engagement and retention, aligning with social identity theory which states that individuals derive part of their self-esteem from their group memberships. Implementing DE&I training enhances understanding and fosters a more equitable work environment.

Implementing Robust Performance Management Systems: A well-defined performance management system, incorporating regular feedback sessions and evaluations, provides employees with insights into their strengths and weaknesses. This fosters self-awareness and provides opportunities for targeted development, aligning with self-efficacy theory. Constructive feedback promotes improvement and enhances job satisfaction, contributing to higher employee retention.

Enhancing Work-Life Integration: Supporting work-life balance through flexible work arrangements (remote work, flexible hours), generous paid time off, and well-being initiatives demonstrates a commitment to employee well-being. This positively impacts job satisfaction and reduces stress, thereby increasing employee engagement and reducing turnover, supporting the concept of job demands-resources model.

Developing Open Communication and Feedback Mechanisms: Establishing open communication channels and feedback mechanisms allows employees to voice concerns and suggestions. Actively listening to and responding to feedback demonstrates that employee opinions are valued, creating a culture of trust and transparency. This improves employee morale and engagement, reinforcing a sense of organizational justice.

Empowering Employees Through Meaningful Work: Assigning challenging and meaningful work aligns with intrinsic motivation and self-determination theory. Providing autonomy and ownership fosters a sense of fulfillment and commitment, increasing job satisfaction and reducing turnover. This also promotes employee growth and development, contributing to longer-term retention.

Continuous Monitoring and Adaptation: Regular employee engagement assessments (surveys, focus groups) provide valuable insights into employee satisfaction and identify areas for improvement. Analyzing this data allows for data-driven decisions, ensuring that retention strategies remain effective and relevant in a dynamic business environment. This reflects a commitment to continuous improvement and adaptation, crucial in today’s volatile market.

Conclusions and Recommendations

Effective employee retention requires a multi-faceted approach that integrates strategic compensation, robust performance management, a culture of recognition, and a commitment to employee growth and development. Organizations must foster a positive and inclusive work environment that prioritizes employee well-being and work-life integration. By implementing these evidence-based strategies and regularly assessing employee engagement, organizations can significantly enhance employee loyalty, reduce turnover, and improve overall organizational performance. Further research should focus on the comparative effectiveness of various retention strategies across different industries and organizational contexts, potentially exploring the intersection of organizational culture and employee well-being on retention outcomes using quantitative and qualitative methods. The insights gained can inform the development of more targeted and effective retention strategies.

Reader Pool: Considering the various theoretical models discussed in this article, which strategies do you believe are most impactful for fostering long-term employee retention, and why?

“`html

Designing Effective Workplace Wellness Programs: A Holistic Approach to Employee Well-being

In the contemporary business environment, characterized by intense competition and rapid change, prioritizing employee well-being is no longer a peripheral concern but a strategic imperative. A robust and healthy workforce demonstrably contributes to heightened productivity, improved job satisfaction, and enhanced organizational performance. This article examines the multifaceted benefits of comprehensive workplace wellness programs and provides a framework for their effective design and implementation. Key concepts explored include the Social Cognitive Theory (SCT), which emphasizes the interplay of personal factors, environmental influences, and behavioral outcomes in shaping health behaviors; the Job Demands-Resources (JD-R) model, which focuses on the balance between job demands and resources in predicting employee well-being; and the Health Belief Model (HBM), which analyzes the individual’s perception of susceptibility, severity, benefits, and barriers to health-related actions.

1. Enhancing Employee Health and Well-being through Proactive Strategies

Effective wellness programs are foundational to improving employee physical and mental health. Applying the tenets of the Health Belief Model, interventions must address employees’ perceived susceptibility to health risks (e.g., through health screenings identifying risk factors), the severity of potential health consequences (e.g., education on the long-term effects of unhealthy habits), and the benefits of adopting healthier lifestyles (e.g., highlighting the advantages of regular exercise and nutritious eating). By providing resources such as on-site fitness centers, health screenings, and workshops on stress management and nutrition, organizations create an environment conducive to positive health behavior change.

2. Fostering Employee Engagement: A Key Driver of Productivity

The JD-R model posits that high job demands coupled with insufficient resources lead to employee burnout and disengagement. Wellness programs directly address this by providing resources that mitigate job demands (e.g., stress management techniques) and enhance resources (e.g., providing access to mental health support, professional development opportunities, work-life balance initiatives). These initiatives, combined with a supportive work culture that values employee well-being, cultivate increased engagement and commitment.

3. Optimizing Productivity and Performance through a Holistic Approach

Investing in employee well-being translates directly into improved organizational performance. Research consistently demonstrates a positive correlation between employee health and productivity. By reducing absenteeism, presenteeism (being present but unproductive due to illness or stress), and healthcare costs (as supported by numerous studies), organizations see a significant return on investment in wellness initiatives. This aligns with the principles of human capital theory, which emphasizes the value of investing in employees’ skills and well-being to enhance organizational effectiveness.

4. Attracting and Retaining Top Talent in a Competitive Market

In today’s competitive talent landscape, organizations must offer comprehensive value propositions that extend beyond compensation. A robust wellness program serves as a powerful differentiator, attracting top candidates and fostering employee retention. This is grounded in the concept of organizational attractiveness, where employees are drawn to organizations that demonstrate a commitment to their overall well-being. The program functions as a significant employee benefit, reducing employee turnover and associated recruitment costs.

5. Cultivating a Positive Organizational Culture

A strong workplace culture significantly impacts employee morale and job satisfaction. Wellness programs contribute directly to a positive work environment by fostering a sense of community, camaraderie, and mutual support. This aligns with organizational culture theories that emphasize the importance of shared values and norms in shaping employee behaviors and attitudes. By prioritizing employee well-being, organizations cultivate a supportive and inclusive environment where employees feel valued and respected.

6. Mitigating Stress and Promoting Mental Well-being

Work-related stress is a pervasive issue impacting both individual and organizational health. The SCT demonstrates that providing employees with the skills and resources to manage stress effectively (e.g., mindfulness training, stress reduction techniques, access to mental health professionals) fosters self-efficacy – their belief in their ability to cope with stressors. This, in turn, promotes resilience and improves overall mental well-being, leading to a healthier and more productive workforce.

7. Personalization and Inclusivity: Tailoring Programs to Diverse Needs

Recognizing the heterogeneity of employee needs, a successful wellness program offers a diverse range of options tailored to individual preferences and circumstances. This includes considering factors such as age, cultural background, physical limitations, and personal health goals. A flexible and inclusive approach ensures that all employees feel supported and empowered to participate. This aligns with the principles of universal design, which seeks to create environments and experiences accessible to all individuals.

8. Leadership Commitment: Role Modeling and Program Success

Leaders play a pivotal role in driving the success of wellness programs. Their active support, participation, and visible commitment to well-being create a culture of health and inspire employee engagement. Transformational leadership theory suggests that leaders who model healthy behaviors and prioritize the well-being of their teams create a more positive and productive work environment. This leadership commitment is essential for ensuring program sustainability and efficacy.

9. Continuous Monitoring and Improvement: Data-Driven Decisions

Workplace wellness programs should not be static initiatives but rather dynamic, evolving systems. Regular evaluation using key performance indicators (KPIs) such as participation rates, employee feedback, and reductions in healthcare costs is crucial. This data-driven approach allows for continuous improvement, ensuring that programs remain relevant and effective in meeting the evolving needs of the workforce. This iterative process of assessment, feedback, and refinement is vital for long-term program success.

10. Leveraging Technology for Enhanced Program Delivery and Engagement

Technology plays an increasingly significant role in the delivery of workplace wellness programs. Digital platforms, wearable devices, and health apps offer opportunities for personalized interventions, improved data tracking, and increased engagement. By harnessing technology, organizations can create more accessible, convenient, and engaging wellness experiences for their employees, leading to better health outcomes.

Conclusions and Recommendations

Workplace wellness programs are not merely a matter of corporate social responsibility but a strategic investment yielding significant returns in enhanced employee well-being, productivity, and organizational success. By employing a holistic approach that integrates elements of SCT, JD-R, and HBM, organizations can design programs that address individual needs and organizational goals. Effective programs must prioritize personalization, leadership support, continuous evaluation, and the strategic use of technology. Further research should focus on exploring the long-term impact of various wellness interventions on different employee demographics and organizational contexts, as well as identifying best practices for measuring the return on investment of these programs. The integration of data analytics and predictive modeling offers promising avenues for optimizing program design and maximizing their impact. The ultimate aim is to create a sustainable ecosystem of well-being that empowers employees to thrive both personally and professionally.

Reader Pool:

Considering the multifaceted benefits presented, how can organizations effectively overcome potential barriers to implementing and maintaining comprehensive workplace wellness programs?

“`

15 Leadership Strategies to Cultivate Innovation and Creativity

In today’s rapidly evolving business landscape, marked by accelerated technological progress and intensified competition, cultivating innovation and creativity within leadership structures is critical for sustained organizational success. This necessitates a strategic approach that surpasses conventional management models. This article explores fifteen evidence-based strategies for fostering a culture of innovation, grounded in established organizational behavior theories and best practices. The aim is to provide a practical framework for leaders to implement, drawing on relevant theoretical underpinnings.

Key Concepts and Theoretical Foundations

Understanding key concepts is paramount before exploring the strategies. Innovation, within the context of organizational behavior, is the process of translating novel ideas into tangible value, be it a new product, service, or process. Creativity, closely linked to innovation, is the generation of original and useful ideas. Growth Mindset, as proposed by Carol Dweck, posits that abilities are malleable and can be developed through dedication and effort, contrasting with a fixed mindset that views abilities as inherent and static. This directly impacts risk-taking and learning from failures. Organizational Culture represents the collective values, beliefs, and norms that shape employee behavior. Psychological safety, a crucial aspect of organizational culture, refers to a shared belief that the team environment tolerates interpersonal risk-taking and constructive challenge without fear of reprisal. Finally, Resource Dependence Theory highlights the importance of access to resources (financial, technological, human) in achieving organizational goals, including innovation.

Strategies for Fostering Innovation: A Practical Approach

1. Establishing Clear Goals and Expectations (Goal-Setting Theory): Clearly defined organizational vision, strategic goals, and performance expectations are crucial. Applying Locke’s Goal-Setting Theory, specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound (SMART) goals provide focus and direction, aligning innovation efforts with overall strategic objectives. This clarity reduces ambiguity and fosters a sense of purpose, motivating employees to contribute to meaningful outcomes. Real-world application: Implementing a balanced scorecard to track progress against SMART goals related to innovation metrics.
2. Cultivating a Growth Mindset (Dweck’s Growth Mindset Theory): Promoting a growth mindset within the organization fosters a culture where challenges are viewed as learning opportunities. This involves providing constructive feedback focused on development, celebrating effort, and reframing setbacks as valuable learning experiences. Practical application involves implementing regular feedback sessions, leadership training on providing constructive criticism, and offering opportunities for skill development.
3. Creating a Culture of Psychological Safety (Edmondson’s Psychological Safety): Employees must feel safe to experiment, take risks, and express ideas without fear of negative repercussions. This requires creating an environment where mistakes are seen as learning opportunities and open communication is encouraged. Leaders must actively model this behavior, demonstrating vulnerability and a willingness to learn. A practical example is implementing regular “failure reviews” where teams analyze past mistakes to learn from them.
4. Leveraging Diversity and Inclusion for Enhanced Creativity (Social Identity Theory & Social Capital Theory): Diverse teams bring a wider range of perspectives, fostering creative problem-solving. Proactive diversity and inclusion initiatives are crucial, coupled with fostering an inclusive environment where all voices are respected and valued. This increases social capital, strengthening team cohesion and enhancing innovative capacity. This involves implementing inclusive recruitment practices and diversity training programs.
5. Providing Resources and Empowering Employees (Resource Dependence Theory): Access to resources is critical for innovation. Leaders must provide employees with the necessary tools, technologies, budget, and training to develop their ideas. Empowerment fosters ownership and accountability, boosting productivity and commitment. Real-world application: Establishing an innovation fund to provide seed money for employee-led projects.
6. Fostering Collaboration Through Cross-Functional Teams (Team Dynamics & Organizational Structure): Cross-functional collaboration allows for idea exchange across departments, sparking innovative solutions. Matrix organizational structures can facilitate this. Practical application: Creating project teams that include members from diverse functions to tackle specific innovation challenges.
7. Allocating Dedicated Time for Creative Problem Solving (Time Management & Resource Allocation): Scheduling dedicated time for creative thinking, such as brainstorming sessions or hackathons, allows focused idea generation. This focused time enhances the effectiveness of creative problem-solving. Real-world application: Implementing dedicated “innovation days” or setting aside specific time blocks each week for brainstorming sessions.
8. Recognizing and Rewarding Innovation (Reinforcement Theory): Acknowledging and rewarding innovative contributions strengthens innovative behaviors. This can involve financial incentives, public recognition, or opportunities for professional development. Real-world application: Establishing an employee recognition program that specifically highlights and rewards innovative contributions.
9. Facilitating Knowledge Sharing and External Learning: Encouraging participation in conferences, workshops, and networking events broadens perspectives and introduces best practices from other organizations. Investing in employee knowledge enhances innovation potential. Practical application: Funding employee attendance at industry conferences and providing opportunities for mentorship and knowledge exchange.
10. Promoting Employee Ownership and Autonomy (Self-Determination Theory): Empowering employees with autonomy over their work increases motivation and innovation. Delegating responsibility fosters ownership and commitment. Real-world application: Implementing agile methodologies that empower teams to manage their own work and make decisions independently.
11. Investing in Continuous Learning and Development: Investing in training programs, mentoring, and knowledge-sharing initiatives enhances employees’ capabilities and fuels innovation. Continuous learning demonstrates a commitment to growth and improvement. Practical application: Developing tailored training programs to enhance employees’ skills in areas relevant to innovation.
12. Building a Positive and Supportive Work Environment: A positive work environment characterized by trust, respect, and psychological safety enhances creativity and collaboration. Fostering strong team dynamics and addressing conflict constructively are critical. Practical application: Implementing team-building activities and providing training on conflict resolution skills.
13. Implementing Idea Management Systems: Utilizing technology platforms to capture, evaluate, and manage innovative ideas provides a structured approach to harnessing collective intelligence. This ensures that ideas are not lost and facilitates collaboration. Real-world application: Implementing an online platform where employees can submit, discuss, and vote on ideas.
14. Establishing Open and Transparent Communication Channels (Organizational Communication Theories): Open communication channels, including regular brainstorming sessions, suggestion boxes, and collaborative platforms, ensure the free flow of ideas. Active listening by leaders is crucial for building trust. Practical application: Implementing regular town hall meetings and utilizing communication platforms that encourage feedback and dialogue.
15. Leading by Example (Transformational Leadership): Leaders must model desired behaviors, demonstrating a willingness to take risks, embrace failure, and actively encourage innovation. This inspires and motivates employees to adopt a similar approach. Practical application: Leaders should actively participate in brainstorming sessions, share their own experiences with failure, and publicly acknowledge and reward innovation.

Conclusions and Recommendations: A Holistic Perspective

Successfully fostering a culture of innovation requires a comprehensive approach that integrates various organizational behavior theories and management principles. The strategies presented provide a robust framework. However, implementation effectiveness depends on the organization’s context, including size, industry, and existing culture. Leadership commitment across all levels, effective communication, and continuous evaluation are crucial for success. Future research should focus on comparative analyses of these strategies’ effectiveness across diverse organizational settings and industries, perhaps using a mixed-methods approach combining quantitative performance metrics with qualitative data on employee experience and perceptions. The successful application of these strategies will lead to improved organizational performance, heightened competitiveness, stronger employee engagement, and the creation of novel products and services. The framework’s applicability spans across organizations of all sizes and sectors. A comprehensive evaluation approach, potentially incorporating qualitative feedback mechanisms alongside quantitative performance indicators, would further refine the understanding of these strategies’ impact and applicability.

Reader Pool: How can organizations best measure the return on investment (ROI) of implementing these innovation strategies, considering both tangible and intangible outcomes?